Her decision to fail all 70 remaining candidates is often interpreted by fans as petty or tyrannical. However, viewed through the lens of a master craftsman, her decision is a necessary critique of mediocrity. The applicants were arrogant; they assumed that because they could kill, they could cook. They ignored the specific history and technique behind sushi, attempting to force their own styles onto a delicate tradition. Menchi’s fury stems from the desecration of her passion. In failing them all, she establishes a high bar for what it means to be a "Hunter"—a title that implies mastery, not just tenacity.
In most shonen, examiners are wise, stoic, and fair. Menchi is emotional, impulsive, and seemingly unfair. Yet, she isn’t wrong. Her lesson—“Read the unspoken rules”—is a harsh but essential filter. The candidates who survive her phase are those who listen, adapt, and respect expertise. menchi hxh
And in a genre where every conflict is solved by punching harder, a woman who fails an entire exam hall over bad sushi is nothing short of iconic. Her decision to fail all 70 remaining candidates
However, fan theories suggest she remains active—possibly tracking down legendary ingredients or training new Gourmet Hunters. Yoshihiro Togashi, the series’ creator, has a habit of leaving beloved side characters open for return, so a future appearance is never off the table. They ignored the specific history and technique behind
: Unlike typical Hunters who track criminals or treasure, Menchi's life is dedicated to the discovery and preparation of rare ingredients.